November 12, 2012

Triple-Layer Peppermint Bark

Several years ago my parents ordered some peppermint bark from William's Sonoma for a Christmas treat.

Since then, there hasn't been Christmas without it. It was a pricey expenditure, but if you've had it, you know... It is worth it.

Of course, that is, until now. ;)

Yes, that's right: I have a Copycat William's Sonoma Peppermint Bark recipe. But -- wait for it -- not only is it a "copycat" recipe...I maintain that it exceeds the taste and texture of the original. Husband, the candy connoisseur of this household, declares that my peppermint bark puts the W.S. product to shame. (I do suppose that makes it only a "semi-copycat" recipe. So William's Sonoma could be *technically* correct when they advertise that their pretty candy "is often copied but never matched in quality or flavor.")

What sets this bark apart from most others is its three layers. The center is delicately minty, rich and just so very slightly soft so that you get this sophisticated balance between the buttery, firm white chocolate and the occasional crisp crunch of the peppermint candy pieces.

It's a lovely, absolutely lovely, little confection.

As my three-and-a-half year old boy solemnly declared as soon as the last piece was consumed: "You will make more of this in the morning."

Why yes, my son, in fact I think I will.

Triple-Layer Peppermint Bark

17 ounces high-quality white chocolate (must be made with real cocoa butter), chopped
20 red-and-white-striped hard peppermint candies, coarsely crushed (about 4 ounces), divided
7 ounces bittersweet or semisweet chocolate (do not exceed 63% cacao), chopped
6 tablespoons heavy whipping cream
1/8 teaspoon peppermint oil (can substitute with 3/4 teaspoon good quality peppermint extract)

- Many Walmart stores now carry Guittard chocolate and white chocolate chips, which is the same brand of chocolate William's Sonoma uses. You may also find them at a local specialty grocer. Find them and buy them. The success of this recipe is dependent entirely on the quality of the chocolate you use. (Of course you can buy really, really expensive stuff if you wish -- but I don't think it's necessary.)

- Regular "Starbright" peppermint candies work just great in this recipe, but you can also use candy canes. For less mess, tap them gently while they're still in the wrapper (or in a plastic Ziploc bag) using a 14-16 oz. can. I didn't want the fine peppermint pieces in my bark, so I used a strainer afterward to sift the larger chunks out.

- I used LorAnn's Pure Peppermint Oil in my bark. Once again, you can find it at Walmart! Look in their craft/cake/candy-making section, not the grocery aisle. A little goes a LONG way.

TIP: To keep the white chocolate layer from remelting when you add the bittersweet chocolate, pour the bittersweet chocolate mixture in three lines down the length of the baking sheet. This speeds up the spreading so that there isn't time for the white chocolate to melt.

Turn large baking sheet bottom side up. Cover securely with foil. Mark 10 x 9-inch rectangle on foil.

Stir white chocolate in metal or glass bowl set over saucepan of barely simmering water (do not allow bottom of bowl to touch water) until chocolate is melted and smooth and candy thermometer registers 110°F. (It will feel warm - not hot - to the touch). Remove from over water. Pour half of the melted white chocolate onto rectangle on foil and set aside. Using an icing or regular spatula, spread chocolate to fill rectangle. Sprinkle with half of the crushed peppermints. Chill until set - at least 15 minutes.

Stir bittersweet chocolate, cream and peppermint oil in another metal or glass bowl set over a saucepan of barely simmering water until just melted and smooth. Cool to barely lukewarm, about 5 minutes. (This step is important - don't skip it. If you don't let it cool, it will melt your white chocolate and while it will still taste fine, it won't look as pretty.) Quickly pour bittersweet chocolate mixture in long lines over white chocolate rectangle. Using your (clean and dry!) spatula, spread bittersweet chocolate in even layer. Refrigerate until very cold and firm - at least 25 minutes.

Rewarm remaining white chocolate that was left in the bowl by again setting it over barely simmering water until it registers about 110°F. Working quickly, pour white chocolate in lines over firm bittersweet chocolate layer; spread to cover. Immediately sprinkle with remaining crushed peppermints. Chill just until firm, about 20 minutes.

Lift foil with bark onto work surface; trim edges. Cut bark crosswise into 2-inch-wide strips. Using metal spatula, slide bark off foil and onto work surface. Cut each strip crosswise into 3 sections and each section diagonally into 2 triangles.

Refrigerate the bark in an airtight container. Can be made up to 2 weeks ahead. Let stand 15 minutes at room temperature before serving.

Happy "bark"-ing! ;)

Linking up to Melt in Your Mouth Monday, Mangia Mondays, Made by You Monday, Market Yourself Monday, Watch Out Martha, Mealtime Monday, A Round Tuit, Hey That's Pin-tastic!, Mop It Up Mondays, Sweet Sharing Monday, Motivate Me Monday, Just Something I Whipped Up, Manic Monday, Marvelous Mondays, Making the World Cuter, Get Your Craft On, Terrific Tuesdays, Tasteful Tuesday, Handmade Tuesdays, Tuesday To-Do, Tuesday Time OutWe Did It Wednesday, Back for Seconds, Well-Crafted Wednesday, Lil Luna, Wonderful Wednesdays, Wow Me Wednesday, Whimsy Wednesday, What We Wore Read and Made, Cast Party Wednesday, Crafty Soiree, House of Hepworths, Blog Stalking Thursday, Transformation Thursday, Creative Juice Thursday, Chic and Crafty, Catch a Glimpse, Somewhat Simple, 20 Below Thursday, Show Off Your Stuff, Create and Share, I'm Lovin It, Friday Flair, Doggone Dirty Craftin, Foodie Friday, Everything but the Kitchen Sink, Flaunt it Friday, It's Inspiration Friday, Simply Creations, Frugalicious Friday,  Kitchen Fun and Crafty Friday, Happy Hour Friday, Keep Calm and Link Up, It's a Hodgepodge Friday, Delightfully Inspiring Thursday, Thursdays Treasures, Linkin Up Thursdays, Made U Look, Fabulous Fridays, Friday Fun Party, Weekend Wonders, Your Creative Timeout  


  1. This looks awesome! It also has some gift-ing potential if you package it up with pretty tins or something. Thanks for the recipe, we may try this!

  2. I love when I can remake something expensive for a lot cheaper. Thanks so much for the directions for your bark - it looks yummy and would be a great gift!

    I've had good success with microwaving my chocolate at low temps for short intervals to be sure it doesn't scorch. I've started doing that instead of using my double-boiler, and I love it because it is much quicker. I'm wondering if I could do the same with this. Blessings!

    1. It is worth a try! I often use the microwave for melting chocolate too, however a couple of times I've had a weird problem with the chocolate and cream seizing up so I didn't want to chance it with this recipe. ;)

  3. This looks divine. We have an annual dessert bake-a-thon around the holidays and I'm going to have to try this out! Thanks so much for sharing and for linking up!

  4. Pinning this! I'll absolutely be trying this out this year!

    Stopping by from Project Inspire :)

    Amy @ Creative Kid Snacks

  5. Hmmm...shall I send you my address so I can eat some as soon as possible?
    This sounds great and I will definitely be adding this to my treat making list this year.
    Thanks for sharing!

  6. This looks amazing! Thanks for sharing the recipe.

  7. I love this recipe!! What a perfect holiday treat!

  8. All I am gonna say is OMG, delish !!!

  9. I've seen the photos on the Williams Sonoma site for this treat and I've never even considered looking at the price! LOL. Yours looks completely awesome, what a perfect neighbor gift! BTW, we homeschool, too!

  10. So, you're sending me some, yes?

  11. i was just thinking about this yesterday. now that i have a recipe, i can make it myself. thanks for sharing : )

  12. Divine! These are going on my Christmas baking list... my friends and co-workers will thank you for it! I'd love for you to share this at Tuesday's Table for the Holidays -

  13. Featured you on my link party today! If you would like a featured button, I have them here: Thanks!

  14. I love WS peppermint bark! Can't wait to try your recipe! Thanks for linking up to the Keep Calm and Link Up! Hope to see you back next week!

  15. This bark is one of my favorite things to eat at Christmas. I'm so glad you shared it with us at Real Housemoms for Fabulous Fridays! I'm following you on FB now and will be back. :)

  16. Well this looks wonderful! I'm so excited to try it out for myself. Thanks for sharing!

  17. this looks sooo good! I am featuring you tomorrow!

  18. This recipe belongs to Orangette who posted it back in 2008

    You should give credit where credit is due since you copied her recipe almost verbatim

    1. Hello Anonymous!

      My recipe is not from Orangette, it is adapted from a recipe I found in Bon Appetit Desserts. The specifics of the directions are derived from Bon Appetit, so it appears Orangette was only getting "inspiration" from them as well. I will note that I changed a few aspects of the recipe to suit my particular tastes. :)

      Thanks for stopping by!

  19. I stumbled across your blog via a Google search for peppermint bark recipes. It does look good, and I hope to try it before Christmas. However, as pointed out above, you really should cite the source of your recipes. It's not copyright infringement per se, but it is good kitchen etiquette. In this case, "adapted from Bon Appetit" really should have appeared somewhere in your original post.